The short version
- El Nuevo Día reported that Gov. Jenniffer González Colón questioned LUMA Energy's hiring of former Supreme Court justices Edgardo Rivera García and Federico Hernández Denton to defend its contract
- González Colón told El Nuevo Día she hopes the Supreme Court will rule the contract was bad for the people of Puerto Rico and should be canceled
- The governor criticized LUMA for recovering less than 6% of federal funds for vegetation management and less than 4% for permanent works and improvements
- Claridad reported that the case reached the Supreme Court after LUMA and the fiscal oversight board failed to move it to federal court
Governor's criticisms of LUMA's legal strategy
Governor Jenniffer González Colón questioned LUMA Energy's decision to retain two former Supreme Court of Puerto Rico justices as part of its legal team in the lawsuit filed by the government to cancel the consortium's contract. El Nuevo Día reported that during an interview on the program "Lo de Hoy," the governor referred to the representation that includes former Associate Justice Edgardo Rivera García and former Chief Justice Federico Hernández Denton.
González Colón stated that the government is litigating the case using public resources and the attorney general, while LUMA pays large law firms that include the two former justices. She told reporters she expects the Supreme Court to validate that the contract was bad for the people of Puerto Rico. The governor added that she has been overseeing the contract from the beginning and filed motions to nullify it and to mediate differences with LUMA.
Also on PuertoRico.com: Puerto Rico power and water outages
What the sources posted
Posts and statements below are the sources' own words, quoted as published. They are not independently verified.
Yo espero. Obviamente, la meta y la aspiración que como gobernadora tengo es que el Tribunal Supremo valide y entienda que este contrato fue malo para el pueblo de Puerto Rico. Es malo para la gente
Our translation: I hope so. Obviously, the goal and aspiration I have as governor is that the Supreme Court validates and understands that this contract was bad for the people of Puerto Rico. It is bad for the people.
The source's own statement, as quoted by El Nuevo Día. Not verified by PuertoRico.com.
Dispute over alleged influence on justices
The governor rejected as completely false any allegations that she made calls to Supreme Court justices seeking a favorable vote in the LUMA case. El Nuevo Día reported that she described such claims as a strategy by LUMA to tarnish the process because the company did not want the case heard in local court.
According to the governor, LUMA and the fiscal oversight board tried to move the lawsuit to federal court, but the federal judge ruled it must be heard in local court under the contract terms. She said LUMA is trying to put undue pressure on the justices because it has two former Supreme Court justices on its team. González Colón also criticized LUMA for spending millions on advertising campaigns instead of investing in vegetation management, substation repairs and transmission infrastructure.
Background on the litigation
Claridad reported that the case against LUMA reached the Supreme Court after it was filed in the Court of First Instance and the parties, including the Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority, the Public-Private Partnerships Authority and the executive branch, requested it be elevated. LUMA attempted to move the case to federal court before Judge Taylor Swain in the PROMESA bankruptcy proceedings, but the judge returned it to local court. The fiscal oversight board tried to intervene in favor of LUMA without success.
Attorney Rolando Emmanuelli Jiménez, who participated in a Colegio de Abogados y Abogadas commission that studied the LUMA contract and found it one-sided, told Claridad the case has significant merits. He noted questions about whether legal requirements were met for the Public-Private Partnerships Authority transaction and that an indefinite contract violates the law. The Supreme Court accepted the case in August but has not yet scheduled oral arguments. The union UTIER and the bar association have appeared in favor of canceling the contract, while the fiscal oversight board and the Association of Industrialists have appeared against cancellation.
Where the sources differ
El Nuevo Día and Claridad both report on Governor Jenniffer González Colón's statements criticizing the LUMA contract and the ongoing Supreme Court case. El Nuevo Día focuses on the governor's direct interview comments about LUMA hiring two former Supreme Court justices, her denial of influencing current justices, low federal funds recovery rates, service interruptions and advertising spending. Claridad centers on an interview with attorney Rolando Emmanuelli Jiménez who discussed the case merits, possible damage to the court's image from influence allegations, and the positions of various parties that have appeared before the court. Both sources agree the case is before the Supreme Court after failing to move to federal court, but Claridad provides more detail on the procedural history and opinions about whether influence attempts occurred.
What the reports do not say
The reports do not state when the Supreme Court is expected to issue a ruling or whether it will hold oral arguments. They do not specify the exact amount of federal funds involved, the total spent by LUMA on legal fees or advertising, or the precise terms of the contract extension the governor criticized. The sources also do not report any response from LUMA Energy, the former justices, or the current Supreme Court justices to the governor's statements.
Sources
Every link below was opened and checked when this story was published. Official means a government body, agency or the organization itself; Reporting means a news outlet.
- Reporting Jenniffer González cuestiona que LUMA Energy contrate a exjueces del Supremo para defender su contrato
- Reporting La gobernadora y el contrato de LUMA
How we checked this
El Nuevo Día reported the governor's interview on "Lo de Hoy" and her specific criticisms of LUMA's legal team and performance. Claridad reported on the procedural background and comments by attorney Rolando Emmanuelli Jiménez. The Supreme Court's ultimate decision on the contract remains pending and rests with that court alone.
Compiled by the PuertoRico.com News Desk from the reports and statements listed above, and checked against them before publishing. It does not include original interviews. Spot an error? Email support@puertorico.com with a link to this story.
Nils Huenerfuerst / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 4.0PuertoRico.com is free, and readers like you keep it that way.
The PuertoRico.com newsroom checks every story against its sources and publishes it free. If this one helped, a contribution of any size keeps the next one free too.
Secure checkout by Stripe: card, Apple Pay, Google Pay or Link.
One payment, nothing to sign up for.
Contributions go to Puerto Rico.com, LLC. They are not charitable donations and are not tax-deductible. Payments are processed by Stripe.
Thank you for keeping PuertoRico.com free.
Your contribution went through. It helps pay for the next story.
Contributions go to Puerto Rico.com, LLC. They are not charitable donations and are not tax-deductible. Payments are processed by Stripe.
